Skip to main content

max / makenotwork

4.1 KB · 84 lines History Blame Raw
1 # Content Protection
2
3 Our approach to protecting creator content: respect fans, defend fair use, and be honest about what we can and can't do.
4
5 ## Our Position on DRM
6
7 We do not implement or facilitate digital rights management (DRM) on content delivered through our platform.
8
9 Modern DRM restricts legitimate users while being routinely circumvented. It requires intrusive software, breaks when companies shut down servers, and punishes people who actually paid.
10
11 ## What We Do Instead
12
13 We give fans clean, unencumbered files. Presigned download URLs are time-limited and tied to authenticated accounts, so casual link-sharing doesn't work. We don't restrict playback or limit how fans use files they've paid for.
14
15 If you need stronger protection than this, we may not be the right platform for your content. We'd rather be honest about that upfront.
16
17 ## Fair Use
18
19 We believe in fair use as a fundamental part of how culture works, not a legal technicality to be minimized.
20
21 ### Our Approach
22
23 We review copyright claims independently of DMCA pressure:
24
25 - **We review claims ourselves.** When we receive a takedown request, we evaluate whether the use might be fair use before acting.
26 - **We give creators time to respond.** We don't immediately remove content; we notify the creator and allow them to make their case.
27 - **We push back on overreach.** Automated takedown systems and overzealous rights holders don't get automatic compliance.
28 - **We consider context.** Commentary, criticism, education, parody, and transformative works deserve protection.
29
30 If someone claims your content infringes their copyright:
31
32 1. We notify you immediately with the full claim details
33 2. You have time to respond before we take action
34 3. We evaluate the claim against fair use principles
35 4. If we believe your use is fair, we'll deny the takedown
36 5. If we're uncertain, we'll discuss it with you
37
38 If we determine content should be removed:
39
40 1. We explain our reasoning
41 2. You can appeal
42 3. We won't remove more than necessary
43
44 ### Limitations
45
46 We have no separate legal team. We will push back on overreach, but if a case requires professional counsel, we may need to defer to your own legal representation.
47
48 What we can promise: we won't roll over at the first legal threat, we won't prioritize our convenience over your rights, and we'll be transparent about our reasoning.
49
50 ## DMCA Process
51
52 We comply with the DMCA's notice-and-takedown requirements, but we exercise the full discretion the law allows:
53
54 ### For Rights Holders
55
56 - Submit claims to [dmca@makenot.work]mailto:dmca@makenot.work
57 - Include all required DMCA elements
58 - Be specific about what content infringes and how
59 - Expect us to actually review your claim
60
61 Automated, bulk, or vague takedown requests will be deprioritized or rejected.
62
63 ### For Creators
64
65 - You'll be notified of any claim against your content
66 - You can submit a counter-notification
67 - We'll restore content if counter-notification requirements are met
68 - We'll fight for you when we believe you're in the right
69
70 ### Repeat Infringers
71
72 We terminate accounts of repeat infringers as required by law. "Repeat infringer" means someone who has had multiple valid claims upheld after review, not someone who has received multiple frivolous claims.
73
74 ## Known Limitations
75
76 **Free content CDN URLs do not expire.** When a CDN is configured, download URLs for free items are static and permanent. Someone with the URL can download without visiting the platform, bypassing download count tracking. This does not affect paid content (which always uses time-limited, authenticated URLs). We consider this acceptable because free content is already publicly accessible to anyone; the URL just skips the middleman. Adding signed CDN URLs would add complexity for no revenue or security benefit.
77
78 ## See Also
79
80 - [Terms of Service]../legal/terms-of-service.md: Full legal terms including content policies
81 - [Copyright & DMCA Policy]../legal/copyright.md: Formal takedown and counter-notification procedures
82 - [Privacy Policy]../legal/privacy-policy.md: How we handle data
83 - [Security]./security.md: How we protect data, encryption details
84